Forgot utensils , our drink order, wrong items brought to our table and she never checked on us...or refilled drinks . … by the Cornell Daily Sun and the Ithaca Times, the high quality of our cuisine is what sets the Carriage House Café apart. The first time I just had a typical omelet with typical sides, which didn't leave me any impression. My wife ordered a vegetable strata and I had the omelette special. The atmosphere was very delightful, and overall we had an enjoyable time. Family members have begun clearing out the furnishings and memorabilia that set the tone for the space. The second time I had the meat strata, which was delicious and satisfying (big portion… Carriage House Cafe. It came with two pieces of toast and some brie cheese in between, covered in watery syrup. Both were absolutely delicious. It is quite special. United States ; New York (NY) Finger Lakes ; Ithaca ; Ithaca Restaurants ; Carriage House Cafe; Search. The first time I just had a typical omelet with typical sides, which didn't leave me any impression. Everyone else really enjoyed their food.More, To be honest I am confused by the positive reviews regarding this restaurant. Our waitress was the worst we’ve had in a LONG time. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. The signs for this are hard to find. So delicious! The Carriage House Café closed on Saturday. Add a carafe of fresh juice to mix with your bottle of bubbly $4, carriagehousecafe, Owner at Carriage House Cafe, responded to this review. One very positive point I will make however, is the decor and location. They touted this as their specialty...but it tasted like boxed aunt Jemima pancake mix. Service was cheerful and attentive. See all restaurants in Ithaca. In other restaurants with mandatory service fees I've been to in New York, they had the sense to exclude this option entirely. Share. There were zero toppings on the plate, sides, or any savory notes to balance the sweetness of the dish, unfortunately, due to the blandness of the Brie. Continue your visit to www.tripadvisor.com. In other restaurants with mandatory service fees I've been to in New York, they had the sense to exclude this option entirely. The atmosphere was very delightful, and overall we had an enjoyable time.More. Side salad, garlic battered NYS gold potatoes, house tomato ginger ketchup, Autumn's Harvest free range eggs, cooked to order with toast, mixed greens, raw cider vinaigrette, fresh seasonal vegetables, Humanely raised chicken breast. Service was cheerful and attentive. were seated, service was a bit slow. Quality. I can think of very few reasons for this other than to pressure people into paying more gratuity or to fool those that did not read there was a mandatory service fee. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. By the time New York State guidelines allowed eateries to reopen outdoor seating and then reduced capacity indoor seating, the Chandler and Woodall families decided to stick with their plan to close, even though there’s no buyer as yet. Shop local! The iconic Brie Stuffed French Toast from the Carriage House. “When they left, they felt fulfilled, relaxed and ready to face the next term paper, work day, exam, busy afternoon or trip ahead of them.”. more, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options, Vegetarian Friendly, brioche french toast stuffed with double crème brie, served with berry coulis, maple syrup, made from house baked brioche served with berry coulis, maple syrup, citrus sour cream pancakes, daily seasonal toppings, maple syrup, egg-custard brioche bread pudding made with Autumn's Harvest eggs, Trinity Valley Milk, blended cheeses, savory filling, large house salad, French style rolled omelet, daily filling, housemade French bread, 2 Autumn's Harvest eggs made to order, 2 pieces of locally raised bacon, housemade French bread, scrambled Autumn's Harvest eggs, McCadam cheddar on a housemade ham, cheddar, scallion scone, Autumn's Harvest eggs to order, McCadam cheddar and ham on griddled French bread. Great atmosphere and beautiful building. Service was lacklustre. Phone 607-645-0152. Too busy fooling around with staff and not providing us service. Try making a reservation or prepared to wait during weekend brunches. We proudly use local grassfed milk, Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Irish Breakfast, Cinnamon Orange, Rooibos Red, Peppermint, Chamomile, Hibiscus, Ginger Lemon, Ask your server for assorted flavors. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in Canada. However, even once we...were seated, service was a bit slow. Claimed. They open at 9 and we just missed the first seating so we had to wait an hour. We look forward to serving you again! “The cafe’s vision of ‘Comfort. Omelet at Carriage House Cafe "I've been here twice. We had the Brie French Toast and Pancake Special. There were zero toppings on the plate, sides, or any savory notes to balance the sweetness of the dish, unfortunately, due to the blandness of the Brie. For the price and wait we expected a lot more. The syrup was watery and I would have preferred real maple syrup. Popular Collegetown cafe business is for sale Although the menu promises nuts, I didn't find any on the plate. June 21, 2020 by Mark H. Anbinder in 14850 Dining. Thank you so much for visiting us! Bar & Lounge Wed-Sat | 4:30-11 PM Sweet & Savory Brie French Toast.